Skip to main content
    S

    Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI)

    Official site

    FINANCIAL SERVICES • INSURANCE - PROPERTY & CASUALTY • NASDAQ

    $103.78
    +1.11 (+1.08%)

    Market Cap: $6.12B

    Last updated: Nov 17, 2026 at 11:06 AM ET

    Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) Earnings: Report Dates and Results

    Updated Oct 22, 2026. Results come from company earnings reports, and estimates are consensus analyst estimates.

    Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) is expected to report earnings on Jan 27, 2027. In the quarter ended Sep 30, 2026, Selective Insurance Group reported EPS of $2.37, above the $1.91 estimate. It beat the EPS estimate in 3 of the last 8 quarters.

    Earnings

    Performance (10Y)

    Beat Rate
    50%(20/40)
    Avg Surprise
    +0.32%
    Streak
    2 Q

    Upcoming Estimates

    Reports Jan 27, 2027 (est.)Period ending Dec 31, 2026
    EPS Consensus$2.79
    Range$2.38 - $3.26
    10 analysts
    Revenue Consensus
    $1.09B
    Range$1.02B - $1.13B
    7 analysts
    Reports Apr 20, 2027 (est.)Period ending Mar 31, 2027
    EPS Consensus$2.16
    Range$1.92 - $2.29
    8 analysts
    EPS Revisions
    7
    0
    30d
    EPS Estimate DriftChange to current
    90d ago$2.09+3.2%
    60d ago$2.09+3.3%
    30d ago$2.09+3.3%
    7d ago$2.13+1.5%
    Current$2.16
    Revenue Consensus
    $1.33B
    Range$1.31B - $1.35B
    5 analysts

    Next Report

    SIGI has an expected report date of Jan 27, 2027. Analysts' consensus for the quarter ending Dec 31, 2026 is 8.6% above the $2.57 reported for the quarter ended Dec 31, 2025.

    SIGI Earnings Call

    The latest SIGI earnings call transcript on file is labeled 2026Q3.

    Read the 2026Q3 transcript

    Earnings History

    Of the 40 quarters below that had an estimate, SIGI beat 20, missed 19 and matched 1. Revenue for the quarter ended Sep 30, 2026 was $1.31B, down 3.0% from $1.35B a year earlier.

    Quarter endedEPSEstimateRangeSurpriseResultYoYAnalystsRevisionsReportedRevenue
    Sep 30, 2026$2.37$1.91$1.53 - $2.23+24.08%Beat+35.4%82 up, 1 downOct 22, 2026$1.31B
    Jun 30, 2026$1.95$1.72$1.39 - $1.91+13.37%Beat+48.9%8N/AJul 23, 2026$1.37B
    Mar 31, 2026$1.69$1.82$1.25 - $2.10-7.14%Miss-4.0%80 up, 3 downApr 22, 2026$1.35B
    Dec 31, 2025$2.57$2.18$1.89 - $2.59+17.89%Beat+58.6%74 up, 1 downJan 29, 2026$1.35B
    Sep 30, 2025$1.75$1.99$1.75 - $2.15-12.06%Miss+25.0%76 up, 0 downOct 22, 2025$1.35B
    Jun 30, 2025$1.31$1.52$1.34 - $1.73-13.82%MissN/A70 up, 4 downJul 23, 2025$1.31B
    Mar 31, 2025$1.76$1.86$1.77 - $2.00-5.38%Miss+32.3%70 up, 3 downApr 23, 2025$1.28B
    Dec 31, 2024$1.62$1.99$1.80 - $2.10-18.59%Miss-16.5%81 up, 3 downJan 29, 2025$1.25B
    Sep 30, 2024$1.40$1.64$1.45 - $1.80-14.63%Miss-7.3%94 up, 2 downOct 21, 2024$1.24B
    Jun 30, 2024-$1.10$1.47$1.15 - $1.74-174.83%Miss-211.1%91 up, 3 downJul 18, 2024$1.19B
    Mar 31, 2024$1.33$1.87$1.71 - $2.04-28.88%Miss-7.6%94 up, 0 downMay 1, 2024$1.16B
    Dec 31, 2023$1.94$1.95$1.72 - $2.10-0.51%Miss+32.9%95 up, 0 downJan 31, 2024$1.10B
    Sep 30, 2023$1.51$1.60$1.45 - $1.76-5.63%Miss+52.5%83 up, 0 downNov 1, 2023$1.07B
    Jun 30, 2023$0.99$0.99$0.99 - $0.990.00%In line-15.4%70 up, 2 downAug 2, 2023$1.03B
    Mar 31, 2023$1.44$1.58$1.44 - $1.68-8.86%Miss+61.8%73 up, 1 downMay 3, 2023$992.65M
    Dec 31, 2022$1.46$1.44N/A+1.39%Beat-6.4%85 up, 2 downFeb 2, 2023$944.91M
    Sep 30, 2022$0.99$1.17$0.99 - $1.30-15.38%Miss-16.1%71 up, 0 downNov 2, 2022$887.84M
    Jun 30, 2022$1.17$1.23N/A-4.88%Miss-36.8%N/A3 up, 0 downAug 3, 2022$857.57M
    Mar 31, 2022$0.89$1.46$1.31 - $1.63-39.04%Miss-47.6%85 up, 1 downMay 4, 2022$838.89M
    Dec 31, 2021$1.56$1.43$1.28 - $1.60+9.09%Beat-15.2%8N/AFeb 3, 2022$862.50M
    Sep 30, 2021$1.18$1.03$0.79 - $1.48+14.56%Beat+11.3%7N/AOct 27, 2021$857.80M
    Jun 30, 2021$1.85$1.26$1.05 - $1.54+46.83%Beat+362.5%7N/AJul 28, 2021$833.15M
    Mar 31, 2021$1.70$1.03$0.88 - $1.15+65.05%Beat+102.4%6N/AApr 28, 2021$796.55M
    Dec 31, 2020$1.84$1.20$1.10 - $1.46+53.33%Beat+34.3%7N/AJan 28, 2021$767.59M
    Sep 30, 2020$1.06$0.97$0.85 - $1.18+9.28%Beat+9.3%7N/AOct 28, 2020$776.57M
    Jun 30, 2020$0.40$0.37$0.26 - $0.40+8.11%Beat-65.5%8N/AJul 29, 2020$682.45M
    Mar 31, 2020$0.84$1.02$0.90 - $1.11-17.65%Miss-6.7%8N/AMay 5, 2020$664.83M
    Dec 31, 2019$1.37$1.10$0.86 - $1.24+24.55%Beat+14.2%8N/AJan 30, 2020$728.90M
    Sep 30, 2019$0.97$1.07$0.97 - $1.14-9.35%Miss-2.0%9N/AOct 30, 2019$710.42M
    Jun 30, 2019$1.16$1.06$0.98 - $1.22+9.43%Beat+14.9%9N/AJul 31, 2019$708.20M
    Mar 31, 2019$0.90$0.94$0.76 - $1.05-4.26%Miss+95.7%9N/AMay 1, 2019$698.96M
    Dec 31, 2018$1.20$0.93$0.74 - $1.07+29.03%Beat+39.5%9N/AJan 31, 2019$636.93M
    Sep 30, 2018$0.99$0.91$0.77 - $1.00+8.79%Beat+37.5%7N/AOct 25, 2018$658.40M
    Jun 30, 2018$1.01$0.88$0.79 - $0.94+14.77%Beat+48.5%6N/AAug 1, 2018$645.79M
    Mar 31, 2018$0.46$0.48$0.36 - $0.80-4.17%Miss-46.5%6N/AMay 2, 2018$620.54M
    Dec 31, 2017$0.86$0.80$0.74 - $0.90+7.50%Beat+14.7%6N/AFeb 1, 2018$621.55M
    Sep 30, 2017$0.72$0.65$0.44 - $0.79+10.77%Beat+16.1%6N/AOct 25, 2017$615.21M
    Jun 30, 2017$0.68$0.73$0.65 - $0.78-6.85%Miss-5.6%6N/AJul 26, 2017$608.40M
    Mar 31, 2017$0.86$0.68N/A+26.47%Beat+30.3%N/AN/AApr 26, 2017$600.47M
    Dec 31, 2016$0.75$0.68N/A+10.29%Beat-7.4%N/AN/AFeb 2, 2017$576.53M
    Last 40 quarters

    Annual EPS

    EPS for the fiscal year ended Dec 31, 2025 was $7.39, up 127.4% from the year before. It was $2.75 for the year ended Dec 31, 2016, the oldest of the 10 fiscal years shown.

    Fiscal year endedEPSChange
    Dec 31, 2025$7.39+127.4%
    Dec 31, 2024$3.25-44.7%
    Dec 31, 2023$5.88+30.4%
    Dec 31, 2022$4.51-28.3%
    Dec 31, 2021$6.29+51.9%
    Dec 31, 2020$4.14-5.9%
    Dec 31, 2019$4.40+20.2%
    Dec 31, 2018$3.66+17.3%
    Dec 31, 2017$3.12+13.5%
    Dec 31, 2016$2.75N/A

    Earnings Calls

    The 8 most recent earnings calls are listed below; the latest, 2026Q3 for the period ended Sep 30, 2026, runs about 5,300 words across 9 speakers.

    CallPeriod endingWordsSpeakersTranscript
    2026Q3Sep 30, 20265,2889
    2026Q2Jun 30, 20265,2769
    2026Q1Mar 31, 20264,5889
    2025Q4Dec 31, 20255,73510
    2025Q3Sep 30, 20255,6909
    2025Q2Jun 30, 20256,3319
    2025Q1Mar 31, 20254,7177
    2024Q4Dec 31, 20245,9628

    2026Q3 Earnings Call

    Opening remarks

    Brad Wilson Senior Vice President Good morning. Thank you for joining Selective's third quarter 2026 earnings conference call. Yesterday, we posted our earnings press release, financial supplement, and investor presentation on the investors section of selective.com. A replay of today's webcast will be available there shortly after this call. Joining me are John Marchioni, our Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer, and Patrick Brennan, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. They will discuss our results and take your questions. During the call, we will reference non-GAAP measures used by insurance and investment professionals to evaluate financial and operating performance, including operating income, operating return on common equity, and adjusted book value per common share. Reconciliations to the most comparable GAAP measures are available in our press release and financial supplement on the investor section of selective.com. We will also make forward-looking statements under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These statements and projections about future performance are subject to risks and uncertainties that we disclose in our SEC filings. We undertake no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements. Now, I'll turn the call over to John.

    John Marchioni Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer Thanks, Brad. We delivered a strong third quarter, highlighted by a 16.9% operating ROE, improved underwriting margins, and excellent net investment income, which increased 16% year-over-year. This was our ninth consecutive quarter of double-digit operating returns, bringing us to 14.3% year-to-date. Our combined ratio of 96.8 improved 1.8 points from a year ago, driven by improvement in Standard Commercial Lines and Personal Lines, and E&S delivered an 86.5 combined ratio. Overall, the quarter demonstrated the earnings strength of our underwriting and investment operations. We remain focused on generating profitable growth by applying greater pricing and underwriting granularity, improving retention on our best-performing business, and increasing new business production in areas that meet our profitability objectives. While executing on these actions to further improve underwriting profitability going forward, we are also laying the foundation for our next phase of growth. In E&S, our retail access initiative has moved from build-out to execution. The structural investments are largely complete. Agency appointments and our underwriting model are in place, and early indicators are encouraging. In addition, we are finding opportunities to thoughtfully expand our brokerage appetite to deepen our longstanding wholesale relationships. We believe this combination, strengthening our wholesale distribution while giving our retail partners access to our E&S capabilities, is a long-term growth lever and supports our diversification objectives across products, geographies, and segments. In personal lines, profitability in our target mass affluent market continues to improve, with our homeowners portfolio gaining traction.

    Frequently Asked Questions About SIGI

    When is Selective Insurance Group's next earnings date?

    Selective Insurance Group's next earnings report is expected for Jan 27, 2027.

    Did SIGI beat earnings estimates last quarter?

    Yes. Selective Insurance Group reported EPS of $2.37 for the quarter ended Sep 30, 2026, above the $1.91 estimate, a 24.08% surprise.

    What EPS do analysts expect from SIGI next quarter?

    The consensus EPS estimate for Selective Insurance Group for the quarter ending Dec 31, 2026 is $2.79 from 10 analysts, with estimates from $2.38 to $3.26.

    How often does SIGI beat earnings estimates?

    Selective Insurance Group beat the EPS estimate in 3 of the last 8 quarters, with an average surprise of -0.21%.